Imagine a global spying network that can eavesdrop on every single phone
call, fax or e-mail, anywhere on the planet.
It sounds like science fiction, but it's true.
Two of the chief protagonists - Britain and America - officially deny its
existence. But the BBC has confirmation from the Australian Government that
such a network really does exist and politicians on both sides of the
Atlantic are calling for an inquiry.
On the North Yorkshire moors above Harrogate they can be seen for miles,
but still they are shrouded in secrecy. Around 30 giant golf balls, known
as radomes, rise from the US military base at Menwith Hill.
Linked to the NSA
Inside is the world's most sophisticated eavesdropping technology, capable
of listening-in to satellites high above the earth.
The base is linked directly to the headquarters of the US National Security
Agency (NSA) at Fort Mead in Maryland, and it is also linked to a series of
other listening posts scattered across the world, like Britain's own GCHQ.
The power of the network, codenamed Echelon, is astounding.
Every international telephone call, fax, e-mail, or radio transmission can
be listened to by powerful computers capable of voice recognition. They
home in on a long list of key words, or patterns of messages. They are
looking for evidence of international crime, like terrorism.
Open Oz
The network is so secret that the British and American Governments refuse
to admit that Echelon even exists. But another ally, Australia, has decided
not to be so coy.
The man who oversees Australia's security services, Inspector General of
Intelligence and Security Bill Blick, has confirmed to the BBC that their
Defence Signals Directorate (DSD) does form part of the network.
"As you would expect there are a large amount of radio communications
floating around in the atmosphere, and agencies such as DSD collect those
communications in the interests of their national security", he said.
Asked if they are then passed on to countries like Britain and America, he
said: "They might be in certain circumstances."
But the system is so widespread all sorts of private communications, often
of a sensitive commercial nature, are hoovered up and analysed.
Journalist Duncan Campbell has spent much of his life investigating
Echelon. In a report commissioned by the European Parliament he produced
evidence that the NSA snooped on phone calls from a French firm bidding for
a contract in Brazil. They passed the information on to an American
competitor, which won the contract.
"There's no safeguards, no remedies, " he said, "There's nowhere you can go
to say that they've been snooping on your international communications. Its
a totally lawless world."
Breaking the silence
Both Britain and America deny allegations like this, though they refuse to
comment further. But one former US army intelligence officer has broken the
code of silence.
Colonel Dan Smith told the BBC that while this is feasible, it is not
official policy: "Technically they can scoop all this information up, sort
through it, and find what it is that might be asked for," he said. "But
there is no policy to do this specifically in response to a particular
companies interests."
Legislators on both sides of the Atlantic are beginning to sit up and take
notice. Republican Congressman Bob Barr has persuaded congress to open
hearings into these and other allegations.
In December he is coming to Britain to raise awareness of the issue. In an
interview with the BBC he accused the NSA of conducting a broad "dragnet"
of communications, and "invading the privacy of American citizens."
He is joined in his concerns by a small number of politicians In Britain.
Liberal Democrat MP Norman Baker has tabled a series of questions about
Menwith Hill, but has been met with a wall of silence.
"There's no doubt its being used as a listening centre," he said, "There's
no doubt its being used for US interests, and I'm not convinced that
Britain's interests are being best served by this."
Home Page